• 0 Posts
  • 51 Comments
Joined 5 months ago
cake
Cake day: July 29th, 2025

help-circle




  • Fascinating, I didn’t realize the Roman Catholic Church didn’t have deaconesses. The Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Churches do, and several Protestant denominations do.

    Ah, right, okay, reading the Wikipedia page, the presence of deaconesses fell off when the church became institutionalized under Constantine and started removing women from leadership roles. Just went downhill from there.

    Good job, Roman Catholic Church. Ignore your own holy text which contains examples of deaconesses in favor of a patriarchal system that was mostly enforced after the Roman government took an interest in the church. 🙄




  • They are literally, physically and governmentally, separate.

    I’m not trying to say that Israel isn’t being horrible in the West Bank (they are), nor am I saying that the pattern of behavior towards Palestinians is not the same in both places (it is), nor am I denying that the overarching conflict is one and the same (it is). I’m saying that the genocidal siege of Gaza, and specifically the ceasefire negotiated with Hamas, do not directly deal with the West Bank nor the Palestinian Authority.

    So it isn’t that the settlers got an “exemption” from the ceasefire, it’s that the ceasefire didn’t deal with that region to begin with.











  • Her performances lean heavily on elaborate set pieces and fifty costume changes.

    And this means she has no talent because…?

    She can barely dance

    Neither can most choral singers, orchestral musicians, concert pianists, does that make them untalented?

    has the most generic singing voice, minimal vocal range

    Ah yes, famously it is impossible to be a talented mezzo-soprano.

    she still writes songs like a 20-year-old despite being 36 years old at this point. The most adversity she’s ever faced is “x celebrity was mean to me”. She has no artistic perspective and nothing interesting to say.

    Valid criticism! But it doesn’t mean she isn’t talented.

    In the grand scheme of things, there are hundreds of THOUSANDS of people with more talent than her making art right this moment.

    Sure, but does that mean she has no talent? There are lots of numbers bigger than 74, does than mean 74 is 0?

    I can’t play an instrument and sing at the same time. I also can’t dance. And there are MILLIONS of people more talented than I am in the world, making art. Does that mean I have no talent? Someone should really let the symphony chorus I’ve been singing in for the last 16 years know.

    The world isn’t black and white, my friend. You don’t have to be Weird Al or Geddy Lee or Mozart to be talented.


  • Listen, I’m not making value statements about her music or her ethics or her politics or anything. I, as a musician, am saying you can’t call her “no-talent.”

    If it wasn’t for her family’s existing wealth, there would had been a possibility thwt we may have never heard of her.

    That’s not unique. The most famous in many fields had a helping hand, because success can be expensive. Wealth does not preclude talent or skill. A person can be talented or skilled and come from a wealthy background. In fact, it tends to be common in music because wealthy parents have the resources to get their kids training and instruments at a young age.

    Taylor Swift music is generic white woman fantasy

    Again, you don’t have to like her music to acknowledge her talents. She’s an accomplished singer/songwriter, performer, and musician regardless of whether you like her content.

    There’s Fandom that are toxic, then there’s hers who drown out any valid criticisms of the artist.

    “Her music is generic white woman fantasy” is valid criticism. The “therefore she has no talent” part isn’t.

    She’s also a MAGA incognito, surrounds herself with MAGAts. Like that saying; if youre having dinner with nazi’s, what does that make you?

    I don’t really know anything about her politics. I do recall a video of her arguing with her publicist and parents because she wanted to support a Democrat. But this is an irrelevant non-sequitur. Even if a person were a card carrying member of the Nazi party, they could still be talented.