Chosen as in “subscriptions” / “followed” / “friends”?
So if it picks from among accounts you’ve opted-in to then it’s not the bad algorithm? That’s not meant as a gotcha, it’s a choice one could make to draw the line, but I don’t know if it’s the one they had in mind. There’s still room there to pick which order it shows your selected things in, but maybe that still mitigates the harm.
Does TikTok have the concept of following or subscribing? I don’t even know…
Things like Lemmy are a little trickier because our model is different. I can subscribe to a community, but then the content in that community is posted by strangers, and then those posts have comments by strangers, all of which require some kind of algorithm to curate. So in this definition showing me strangers shitposts is “no algorithm” if I’m subscribed to the shitpost community, but it isn’t allowed to suggest a shitpost if I’m not in that community?
It’s a line that could be drawn, but it remains to be seen if that’s the line they have in their minds.
Lemmy sorts by new, top and comment count, all of which are easily checkable, and I imagine hot and active are too. These aren’t algorithms because their methods aren’t hidden.
The algorithm here means showing content to one that wasn’t directly chosen, e.g. SEO on Google.
Sense 4 (Wiktionary)
Chosen as in “subscriptions” / “followed” / “friends”?
So if it picks from among accounts you’ve opted-in to then it’s not the bad algorithm? That’s not meant as a gotcha, it’s a choice one could make to draw the line, but I don’t know if it’s the one they had in mind. There’s still room there to pick which order it shows your selected things in, but maybe that still mitigates the harm.
Does TikTok have the concept of following or subscribing? I don’t even know…
Things like Lemmy are a little trickier because our model is different. I can subscribe to a community, but then the content in that community is posted by strangers, and then those posts have comments by strangers, all of which require some kind of algorithm to curate. So in this definition showing me strangers shitposts is “no algorithm” if I’m subscribed to the shitpost community, but it isn’t allowed to suggest a shitpost if I’m not in that community?
It’s a line that could be drawn, but it remains to be seen if that’s the line they have in their minds.
Lemmy sorts by new, top and comment count, all of which are easily checkable, and I imagine hot and active are too. These aren’t algorithms because their methods aren’t hidden.